Comment on Is Christianity real or tampered? by j.k.harwood2

Parent Post: Is Christianity real or tampered? · In Reply To

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 6:34:07 PM · permalink

27 bumps

hyokkim · 5/20/2026, 6:38:12 PM · permalink

25 bumps

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 6:43:58 PM (edited) · permalink

22 bumps

hyokkim · 5/20/2026, 6:48:16 PM · permalink

21 bumps

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 6:49:39 PM · permalink

18 bumps

hyokkim · 5/20/2026, 7:05:56 PM · permalink

16 bumps

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 7:07:07 PM · permalink

13 bumps

hyokkim · 5/20/2026, 7:09:09 PM · permalink

9 bumps

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 7:13:12 PM · permalink

7 bumps

hyokkim · 5/20/2026, 7:38:06 PM · permalink

4 bumps

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 7:51:16 PM · permalink

2 bumps

hyokkim · 5/20/2026, 7:53:51 PM · permalink

1 bump

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 7:15:10 PM · permalink

2 bumps

hyokkim · 5/20/2026, 7:39:55 PM · permalink

1 bump

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 7:09:23 PM · permalink

3 bumps

hyokkim · 5/20/2026, 7:41:05 PM · permalink

2 bumps

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 7:48:55 PM · permalink

1 bump

j.k.harwood2 · 5/20/2026, 6:36:16 PM · permalink

Yes, James — that is a strong and very human reading of the Abraham and Isaac account.

In Genesis 22, the line that stands out is when the angel says:

“Now I know that you fear God…”

That does not mean God lacked knowledge beforehand. In classical biblical understanding, God already knew Abraham’s heart. But Abraham had not yet walked through that moment in embodied obedience. There is a difference between God knowing the outcome and a human being becoming the kind of person who has actually chosen obedience under unbearable pressure.

So your framing is powerful:

God already knew. Abraham needed to know.

Abraham may have been wrestling right up to the last breath before the knife was stayed. Not necessarily because he wanted to disobey God, but because every natural human instinct would have screamed against it: fatherhood, love, grief, confusion, fear, maybe even “Did I hear God correctly?”

The test was not for God’s information. It was for Abraham’s formation.

It revealed Abraham to himself. It proved that his faith was not just belief in promise, but surrender to the Promiser — even when obedience seemed to threaten the very promise God had given him.

And then God stopped him.

That matters deeply. God did not desire Isaac’s death. He desired Abraham’s surrendered trust. The ram was provided. The son was spared. And the story becomes a shadow of a greater truth: where Abraham’s son was spared, God’s own Son would not be.

So yes — I think your insight is sound:

Abraham’s final victory may not have been that he never struggled.

It may have been that, despite the struggle, he finally yielded his will to God’s will.  
  
ChatGPT

1 bump

Signature