Comment on Two things all American antisemites should understand before uttering another word. by taijireality

Parent Post: Two things all American antisemites should understand before uttering another word. · In Reply To

taijireality · 3/11/2025, 5:52:15 AM · permalink

6 bumps

saarnok · 3/11/2025, 12:51:45 PM · permalink

There's a reason why I consistently put quote marks around "The Jews".  
  
As should be apparent from pointing out that criticism of ANY bad guy who happens to be Jewish receives the response "antisemitism" it is THE BAD GUYS who've successfully dragged every other "Jew" in the world into their category, and MOST of them have bought into the same idea.  
  
Every once in a while we'll see some dirtbag get all indignant that someone is daring to question a JEW, that someone is attempting to hold a JEW accountable. And since other notable Jews don't condemn this kind of thing the rest of us are being perfectly reasonable in assuming they approve.  
  
Israel, our "greatest ally" doesn't even extradite criminals. Many people have noted that Jewish pedophiles escape to Israel, but it's really criminals of any sort.  
  
As to the Italian mob, unlike the Jewish mob, they didn't establish their home country's government. They didn't manage to turn Italy into a protectorate for their criminal members. They didn't manage to make virtually every person of Italian decent into cheerleaders for their mob. They didn't spend a hundred YEARS elevating a pedophile rapist murderer to some sort of sainted victim status to prove the point that "The Jews" are not to be held to the same standards as anyone else. They don't have their own peculiar holy books in which they claim everyone other than themselves is sub-human. They don't get to scream about being "persecuted" every time someone points out their wrongdoing.  
  
And all that said: Even if I DO say "the Italians" in some context of mob activity, I don't have to spell it out that I'm not talking about some moral failure or degeneracy peculiar to ALL Italians.  
  
It's not even necessary to identify someone as a "Jewish" reprobate, they'll do it themselves, and very loudly at that.  
  
And while I'm very much getting your point that people reacting to their evil actually plays into the narrative they've spun to their own followers that people are going to see them as evil, I'm not getting the sense that you're advocating a better method of dealing with them.  
  
You apparently believe that they have the means to kill the planet, which means it's utterly inevitable that they will do so. It's just a matter of when, not if. All it needs is for the right faction to be controlling the government, and... poof!  
  
So, you don't seem to want a solution for what they're doing wrong, but you are advancing a "solution" of sorts for what we're doing wrong, which is to stop telling the truth.  
  
Now, I'm sure you'd like to object to how I've characterized your position, but stop and think for a bit: Is there any way to express what you're trying to say that isn't going to boil down to "Stop telling the truth."?  
  
I'd like to add a little something here about the holocaust. Whether intentional or not, (And I do believe it's intentional.) the never ending, always increasing narrative of the holocaust serves the purpose of keeping Israelis in particular, but all Jews generally along with all zionists of whatever stripe justifying whatever atrocities "The Jews" commit. That's what the narrative is for. That's why it's promoted. That's why it's constantly expanded on.  
  
So, your criticism may well be valid, but what constructive advice do you have? Rather than a "don't", what's your "do"?

4 bumps

taijireality · 3/12/2025, 7:23:24 AM · permalink

3 bumps

Signature