soj.ooO
BETA
The social discussion platform
Home
Pochas
Channels
Videos
Log in
Sign up
Sign up
Home
Pochas
Channels
Videos
Log in
Sign up
Parent Post: Art, ethics, and disobedience
S
saarnok
·
11/22/2026, 3:28:52 AM
·
permalink
Yes. The problem for the morally/ethically aware is to discern the go/no-go test to apply in order to determine the correct time to resist authority. It's more than a little trying to set aside our "feels" and examine our principles, rusty as they are, to determine where we ought to stand. If we can't articulate in language other's can understand why we're making a stand, then we face the uncomfortable reality that our positions are on shaky ground.
Save
Cancel
9
bumps
Share
seraphima
·
11/22/2026, 2:43:51 PM
·
permalink
How do you know when you're actually articulating something clearly to someone else in a language they understand? Are you confident that you communicated clearly and effectively only when they show signs of understanding? I mean, basically, how do you know if there's a problem with the given communication and or if there's a problem with their reception/(in)ability to understand? Since the validity of my position is apparently dependent on my ability to communicate my stand, I want to ensure that my conscience is clean when making a determination. What's your advice?
Save
Cancel
6
bumps
Share
S
saarnok
·
11/22/2026, 6:30:41 PM
·
permalink
I wrote this part after writing everything else. Don't get too concerned about it. Decide who your writing is for. Perhaps the majority of the time what we write is a signal, a ping looking for a responding ping. There's nothing wrong with that. It's only when we imagine we're attempting to influence the thinking of people who don't already have the viewpoint we imagine they should have that we need to concern ourselves with clarity to a wide audience. What I originally wrote: Obviously the only time you can be reasonably certain is when they demonstrate what looks to you like understanding. And you can't be entirely certain then. Your position may be perfectly valid, utterly rock solid and capable of taking on all comers. But, if you can't articulate that to people who you'd like to inform, then you either need to sharpen your message or understand that they need to grow into a point where your message becomes understandable. When speaking to a general audience it's generally best to keep things at the most primordial level you can articulate. Or to put it another way: Keep the message so simple that people can grasp at least that one point with an extremely limited buy in to your position. From out internal certainty of comprehension it often seems as though we're speaking to a universally accepted concept, and that's rarely actually the case. We unintentionally trigger people's defense mechanisms through the use of terms that are often completely innocuous to us. Once those defenses are raised, that defensive filter of the presumed underlying message is generally better at holding it's defenses than any attempt we can make for our message. Sometimes we can use that effect to our advantage in a limited sense by making the trigger so feature forward that it is perceived as an attention grabbing gambit. For instance: If I preface something with words similar to: "Our Lord Satan", it's going to be so over the top that people who would ordinarily throw up a defensive filter might be inclined to look for the ironic reversal of the implied message. Babylon Bee uses this technique (Obviously in a artful manner) to enable people to understand their messages. A long time ago I was advised to write in such a manner that I could not be misunderstood. I still consider that advice to be less than brilliant. If you know your audience well enough, perhaps it's possible. It's generally not possible.
Save
Cancel
4
bumps
Share
seraphima
·
11/22/2026, 6:56:04 PM
·
permalink
I appreciate your insight a lot. Thank you very much for taking time to share with me. 🫂
Save
Cancel
2
bumps
Share
Signature
Loading…
Verify locally
Close