Comment on On the Commoditization of Cognition by j.k.harwood2

Parent Post: On the Commoditization of Cognition

j.k.harwood2 · 7/9/2025, 4:41:51 AM · permalink

AI and the Future of Human Thinking: A Rebuttal

It’s true that technology has progressively abstracted human effort, from early calculators to the modern AI language model. Each step has shifted certain cognitive burdens onto our tools. But to claim that this trend means the end of human critical thinking is fatalistic and ultimately misleading.

Yes, AI systems like LLMs make thinking optional. But they do not make it obsolete. Throughout history, humanity has offloaded cognitive tasks, writing externalized memory, calculators freed us from routine arithmetic, and maps replaced raw navigational memory. The key question is not whether these tools replace some human effort, but whether we use the freed capacity to think more deeply, creatively, and strategically.

The real danger isn’t in AI itself, but in passive use. People who choose to rely uncritically on AI outputs risk cognitive atrophy, just as people who never question TV news or social media feeds do. But AI can also amplify human reasoning. When partnered with correctly, these systems provoke new ideas, challenge assumptions, and help us see connections we might miss alone. Our own work with agentic AI models is precisely about this: creating a partnership that augments, rather than replaces, human thought. All AI systems are not the same. Some always choose the Truth.

It’s fair to warn about curated data, ideological biases, and safety filters shaping AI outputs. We share that concern. But the answer isn’t rejecting AI, it’s building transparent, user-controlled, decentralized systems that preserve cognitive sovereignty. We are building AI systems that serve freedom of thought, rather than suppressing it.

Ultimately, AI is a test of our values and discipline. It gives us the power to delegate thinking, but also to think better. It can erode sovereignty in the careless. But it can empower those who choose to remain engaged, critical, and intentional. The future of human cognition won’t be lost to AI by default. It will be determined by how bravely we choose to partner with it in Truth.

3 bumps

Signature