Comment on Twilight Sleep: America’s MKUltra-Style Experiment on Birth by dickie

Parent Post: Twilight Sleep: America’s MKUltra-Style Experiment on Birth

dickie · 7/5/2026, 9:53:36 AM (edited) · permalink

![image](https://us-lax-1.linodeobjects.com/sojooo/comments/2835/1783245214993-04d70f0898a80534.png)
I helped my wife deliver three babies unassisted.  
  
That does not make me anti-hospital. Hospitals are where you go when birth becomes dangerous: hemorrhage, fetal distress, infection, prematurity, surgery, or a newborn who needs immediate intervention.  
  
But it does mean I know birth is not automatically a medical malfunction that requires an institution to take ownership of everyone in the room.  
  
And the timeline is revealing.  
  
In 1900, almost all U.S. births happened outside hospitals.  
  
In the early 1900s, Twilight Sleep arrived: morphine and scopolamine, marketed as painless childbirth. In practice, it could produce amnesia, delirium, prolonged labor, forceps use, and greater danger to newborns.  
  
By 1940, hospital births were already the majority. Only 44% of U.S. births still occurred outside hospitals.  
  
By 1969, only about 1% occurred outside a hospital.  
  
Then came the Baby Boom, 1946 through 1964, right in the middle of this takeover.  
  
And circumcision was part of that same institutional model.  
  
A national survey of boys born from 1949 through 1958 found that more than three-quarters had been circumcised. In other words, for a huge share of Baby Boom boys, the hospital birth package did not just mean being separated from mom, put behind nursery glass, and placed on a feeding schedule. It also meant an irreversible surgical procedure before they could even leave the building.  
  
The government’s reliable national hospital data begins in 1979. It shows newborn circumcision was still routine: 64.5% in 1979, 58.3% in 2010. More recent hospital data found the rate fell from 54.1% in 2012 to 49.3% in 2022. So it is declining, but it is still treated as normal for roughly half of male newborns in American hospitals.  
  
Drug the mother.  
  
Take the baby.  
  
Put the baby behind glass.  
  
Feed the baby when the hospital schedule says.  
  
Tell the mother formula is modern convenience.  
  
Then, for boys, add an elective and irreversible surgery before the child can consent.  
  
Then call it modern care.  
  
Formula is not poison. Bottle-fed babies can be deeply loved. Circumcision does not automatically create attachment disorders. Hospitals are not evil. Medical intervention is not automatically abuse.  
  
But the old hospital model was not built around maternal autonomy, bonding, dignity, or the assumption that families should remain together unless there was a medical reason to separate them.  
  
It was built around control, liability, schedules, efficiency, and the assumption that birth was too painful, too unpredictable, too female, and too inconvenient to trust.  
  
Hospitals save lives when something goes wrong.  
  
They should not be treated as the automatic owner of every birth, every newborn, or every decision made in the first hours of a child’s life.

3 bumps

Signature