Comment on [deleted by author] by tengoshu

tengoshu · 3/9/2025, 8:53:54 PM · permalink

The claim that Islam can only be fully practiced in a Muslim-majority state is historically inaccurate. Some of the earliest Islamic caliphates ruled over vast territories where Muslims were a minority, yet Islamic governance thrived, justice was upheld, and religious freedom was granted to non-Muslims.

**1\. The Rashidun Caliphate (632–661 CE)**

During the early conquests, the Muslim rulers governed regions where non-Muslims were the majority, such as Egypt, Persia, the Levant, and North Africa. In these regions:

Non-Muslims maintained autonomy in their religious and civil affairs. The dhimma system allowed Christians, Jews, and other communities to govern their own personal matters according to their laws.

Muslims were a ruling minority but did not force conversion on the population. Islam spread gradually through trade, cultural exchange, and the justice of Islamic governance.

Religious institutions were protected. Churches and synagogues continued to operate, and religious leaders retained their authority over their communities.

**2\. The Umayyad Caliphate (661–750 CE)**

Under the Umayyads, the Muslim minority ruled over vast lands where non-Muslims (Christians, Zoroastrians, Jews, Hindus) formed the majority, including:

Spain (Al-Andalus): When Muslims entered Spain in 711 CE, the majority of the population was Christian. The ruling Muslims allowed religious minorities to keep their traditions, laws, and places of worship. Many Jews and Christians flourished under Muslim rule, particularly in science, philosophy, and administration.

Persia &amp; Central Asia: The Persians, who were predominantly Zoroastrian, continued to practice their faith for centuries. Persian culture deeply influenced Islamic civilization, and Persian scholars contributed immensely to Islamic sciences.

Islamic governance was built on principles of justice, not forced assimilation. Conversion was neither demanded nor rushed, and societies remained religiously diverse for centuries.

**3\. The Abbasid Caliphate (750–1258 CE)**

The Abbasids ruled an empire where non-Muslims were still a majority in many provinces.

The House of Wisdom (Bayt al-Hikma) in Baghdad: The Abbasids encouraged interfaith intellectual collaboration, where Muslims, Christians, and Jews worked together to translate Greek, Persian, and Indian texts into Arabic.

Tolerance and Economic Inclusion: Non-Muslims occupied high-ranking positions in government, including Christian physicians, Jewish financiers, and Persian administrators.

During this period, the Muslim minority ruled effectively, allowing religious freedom and benefiting from the contributions of non-Muslim scholars and officials.

**4\. The Ottoman Empire (1299–1922 CE)**

Though the Ottoman Empire became majority-Muslim over time, it ruled for centuries with large non-Muslim populations.

The Millet System: Different religious communities (Christians, Jews, Armenians, etc.) had their own courts and laws. They paid the jizya tax but were otherwise free to practice their religions, govern their internal affairs, and engage in trade and administration.

Jews and Christians Thrived: After the fall of Granada in 1492, many Jews and Muslims were expelled from Christian Spain. The Ottomans welcomed them, and Jewish communities flourished in Istanbul and Thessaloniki.

Conclusion: Islam Thrived Under Muslim-Minority Rule

Islam was not only practiced but flourished under early Islamic rule, even when Muslims were a numerical minority. The key was justice, not population size.

The caliphs ensured that non-Muslims had freedom in their personal and religious matters.

Conversion to Islam was not forced but occurred over centuries through trade, intermarriage, and intellectual exchange.

Muslims practiced Islam freely, even when they were a minority, because Islamic governance ensured the protection of religious obligations.

Thus, the idea that Islam can only be practiced in a Muslim-majority state contradicts history. Islam thrives wherever justice, wisdom, and sincerity in governance exist.

2 bumps

Signature