Comment on I have a dream that one day both Jew and Gentile will stand together by carp30mnia

Parent Post: I have a dream that one day both Jew and Gentile will stand together

carp30mnia · 3/7/2025, 7:22:18 AM · permalink

Firstly, wish you the best and hope you're never put off the platform with all the 'Jew' mentions. Diversity of thought is much needed here as much as everywhere else. It's good to see posts like this. Also Gal Gadot is badass. Anyway, in response to your post:  
  
**Every group has it's bad actors.** At the end of the day we're all human, any bad actions taken by Jewish individuals isn't somehow special. And for every demographic, you're totally right: average everyday Joes outnumbers the bad folks by a ton.  
But for better and worse, humans love stories and archetypes. Depending on which group is telling the story, there will always be some other group cast as the villain without question. And this inevitably entails: dehumanization and blatant ignoring of individual moral diversity of said group.  
  
**In modern day there's a special type of black-and-white narrative meta** which casts two groups as conveniently either 100% oppressor (irredeemable villain) or 100% oppressed (innocent underdog hero) with zero nuance attached. For anyone with reason, it should be troubling how a whole class of people can have their humanity stripped from them as soon as they are labeled 'oppressors'. And then select extremists from the 'oppressed' class group can get away with oppressive/harmful language and actions with less consequences or public outrage when aimed at the 'oppressor' group (*after all how can 'David' harming 'Goliath' be immoral*?).  
  
Ex: An 'oppressor/colonizer' can't be a victim, not even babies etc... which is absolute horseshit. (You can see it in some awful reactions to the Bibas family tragedy and October 7th generally). You'll strangely find even self-defense, blind application of the justice system, or disdain against an 'oppressed' perpetrator equated with further oppression and thus unacceptable, even if said 'oppressed' did something heinous. If a person can only be afforded empathy so long as they're the 'right victims'... (and not on account of oh, I don't know maybe... *an individual being the victim in this instance*) and only granted full condemnation if they're the 'right perpetrators'... then humanity has lost the plot per usual.   
  
**It's almost as if 'making things fair' now means having to be selective with moral outrage per identity of the person**, when we should be condemning actions based on the actions themselves - *not by physical properties of who is committing them.*  
**%%Whatever happens, do not feel guilted into feeling bad for something you yourself did not do%%**. Europeans have been dealing (and failing lol) with this 'moral meta' for a while, and unfortunately Jews are having now to deal with this new vector of antisemitism. The sooner identity politics is purged, the better for everyone. It'll be an ideal world when we can all collectively take out our trash that comes in every color and creed.  
  
All that is to say, like you, I also hope humanity will one day truly evaluate strictly on an individual by individual basis and stop using generalizations to unequally weigh human lives.  
\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_  
  
On a sidenote: when I'm dawning my full conspiracy cap, lately I've been thinking rise in recent antisemitism (the genuine kind) is gearing up for the end-times prophecies (if you know you know). But whether those steps are happening organically or consciously being used as a guide by apocalypse-invokers is a whole other convo lol.

9 bumps

okinawajawa · 3/7/2025, 10:43:15 AM · permalink

2 bumps

heidleberger · 3/7/2025, 6:08:34 PM · permalink

3 bumps

okinawajawa · 3/7/2025, 6:59:40 PM · permalink

1 bump

tajudeen_bin_tijani · 3/7/2025, 10:16:29 AM · permalink

1 bump

Signature