Comment on okay here me out, what if SHARIA STATES OF AMERICA? by necr0phagist

Parent Post: okay here me out, what if SHARIA STATES OF AMERICA? · In Reply To

necr0phagist · 4/26/2025, 10:51:25 PM · permalink

You’re incredibly hateful. As an upper-caste Hindu myself, I can say that I do not oppress my Dalit brothers. While some might, and I condemn that. I firmly stand against it. I believe in equal rights for all. I was born into the warrior class — known as the Kshatriyas — traditionally regarded as the second-highest caste. I have swords in my house stained with blood. My ancestors fought for what was right. They didn't discriminate either. Hindutva is exactly how we tackle casteism. Modi is a Dalit himself. Did you know that? I have no problem with Dalits rising.   
  
I hate Islam because it originates from Arabia, is written in Arabic, and contains numerous desert references, such as camels and even bizarre practices like drinking camel urine —  I can cite a Hadith to support my claim:  
  
*Sahih al-Bukhari (Book of Medicine, Hadith 5686):*

*Narrated Anas bin Malik:*

*Some people from the tribe of 'Ukl or 'Uraina came to Medina and fell ill. The Prophet (ﷺ) ordered them to go to the herd of camels and drink their milk and **urine (as a medicine)**. So they went as directed, and after they became healthy, they killed the shepherd of the Prophet and drove away the camels. The Prophet (ﷺ) sent men in their pursuit and they were caught and brought, and he had their hands and feet cut off and their eyes branded with heated pieces of iron.*

My problem with Islam goes beyond its cultural elements, which I personally view as less developed, or the style of its sermons, which I find grating to my ears. And that’s saying a lot, given that I’m someone who listens to technical death metal. On top of that, I don't believe prophet Muhammad was really a prophet.  
  
Before Islam, Arab society was fragmented, with many tribes and no unifying religion like Christianity or Judaism. Arabs often felt culturally and politically inferior to the powerful Christian Byzantines and Persian empires. Islam emerged as a unifying force, giving the Arabs a shared identity and pride, helping them rise rapidly on the world stage. So Islam was simply a sham. It might sound good to a lot of warrior class men, including me like I stated earlier. Infact, there are quite a lot of appealing things in the quran but it's a fake religion. Muhammad revealed the verses gradually and not all at once. What kind of god does that? It's was all so convenient for your so called prophet innit?  
  
On the other hand, hinduism is far richer and doesn't rely on a book. Hinduism does not require you to pray to cows or believe they are divine. Cows are respected as symbols of life, motherhood, and non-violence, but this respect is cultural, not a strict religious commandment. Worship of cows is not central to Hindu practice; the core of Hinduism is about following dharma, seeking truth, and understanding the divine in various forms. Even if you don't believe in cow worship, you are still very much a Hindu, as the faith values inner devotion and personal understanding over rigid rules. So if you are going to insult me about that, you are already defeated. I follow advaita vedanta. I  meditate like kings used to do back in the day called yajna. I connect with my inner being when I do that. Islam is simply inferior I am afraid

7 bumps

earthmightiest · 4/27/2025, 6:35:07 PM · permalink

"You’re incredibly hateful. As an upper-caste Hindu myself, I can say that I do not oppress my Dalit brothers."  
\- you do.  
  
"While some might, and I condemn that."  
\- you call the entire India, some?  
there is a reason why Dalit exist.  
if 'some' might.. there is no such things as Dalit existence in the first place. everyone would diss the 'some' people and call them out as racist.  
  
"Some people from the tribe of 'Ukl or 'Uraina came to Medina and fell ill. The Prophet (ﷺ) ordered them to go to the herd of camels and drink their milk and urine (as a medicine)."  
\- emphasize 'as medicine'. i rest my case.  
  
can moslem eat snake? no  
can moslem eat snake as last resort medicine? yes.  
  
 Muhammad revealed the verses gradually and not all at once. What kind of god does that? It's was all so convenient for your so called prophet innit?  
\- congratz the quran already. literally. directly. answered your allegation  
“And said those who disbelieved, ‘Why has the Quran not been revealed to him all at once?’ (It has been sent down) in this way (i.e. in parts) so that We make your heart firm, and We revealed it little by little.“

(Quran 25:32)  
  
“And We have divided the Quran in portions, so that you may recite it to the people gradually, and We have revealed it little by little.

(Quran 17:106)

In this verse, Allah is saying that the Quran is meant to be read and recited in sections. That people are meant to hear it, and learn from it, over time. The Quran itself is not designed to be taken in all at once. The gradual revelation of the Quran allowed for matters to be resolved as they came up. It also gave people time to understand and apply the information.

We can see how both of these reasons interact by taking a look at the life of the Prophet (pbuh) and the companions that lived with him. During the life of the Prophet (pbuh), any incident that required explanation was responded to in the Quran. It is much easier to remember how to deal with a situation in the future if you are guided through it the first time around. This occurred multiple times throughout the life of the Prophet (pbuh).  
  
"On the other hand, hinduism is far richer and doesn't rely on a book."  
\- hindu A believe in Ganesha, hindu B believe in Shiva, hindu C believe in Brahma, hindu D believe in some hindu god even indians don't recognize.  
ganesha order this, shiva order that, Brahma order something else entirely,.. which one of command should people follow?  
  
ps: no one converted to hinduism.. only a handful of western hippies in drugs and weeds. Hindu is the inferior one. everyone see you as a walking joke.

6 bumps

necr0phagist · 4/28/2025, 12:49:00 PM · permalink

5 bumps

earthmightiest · 4/29/2025, 6:03:30 PM · permalink

4 bumps

necr0phagist · 4/30/2025, 12:15:19 AM · permalink

3 bumps

earthmightiest · 4/30/2025, 3:45:46 PM · permalink

2 bumps

necr0phagist · 5/3/2025, 11:37:08 AM · permalink

1 bump

Signature