Comment on Jews, Christians and Muslims by saarnok

Parent Post: Jews, Christians and Muslims · In Reply To

saarnok · 9/30/2025, 2:21:51 PM · permalink

I have to stop and fix a BIG error on my part which I didn't notice in the first fifteen minutes I spent looking into this, and it's a really big problem for your claims and implications. You're either performing taqiyya or are incredibly ignorant.  
  
Roughly 85% of Islam is Sunni. That's most of Islam. The remainder is almost entirely Shia. Only 2-3% of Muslims worldwide fall outside these two groups. The first group you're claiming do practice mutah, though they've explicitly rejected it as a practice through their hadiths which you have explicitly rejected. The Shia, who you've not explicitly rejected DO practice mutah.  
  
I've spent half an hour of research into this subject and can now make your case better than you can. A LOT better!  
  
Here's YOUR case, made on YOUR behalf:  
  
While "mutah" prostitution is a widespread problem in Muslim communities, it has been widely condemned and explicitly outlawed by the majority Sunni (87%) and is not accepted as a social norm even in most Shia controlled regions, including those where it is fully legal under law.  
  
It is not unlike prostitution in Christian communities which almost all recognize as a shameful practice, not supported by the Christian religion anymore than it is supported by the Muslim religion. Even in Shia controlled countries where it is fully legal it is still regarded as shameful by most.  
  
You've still got a little problem though. You're blaming the Sunni as allowing this practice while their hadiths forbid it. Actually it's a huge problem for you. Because while I'm not really up on all the religious intricacies of how Muslims escape moral complications of British grooming gangs, pedophilia, rampant rape, murder, etc., with my half hour of research. It's a well known phenomenon. And it's well known that it's explicitly an Muslim sourced problem.  
  
And don't keep trying to ask some leading question about silly Christian beliefs in an effort to deflect from yours. They don't try to deflect to "what about Islam" if we're interrogating their nonsense. They at least have the honor to argue from their own writings.

2 bumps

saarnok · 9/30/2025, 2:35:44 PM · permalink

1 bump

Signature