Comment on The best socks I've tried in my life.......... by dickie

Parent Post: The best socks I've tried in my life..........

dickie · 7/2/2026, 11:45:55 AM (edited) · permalink

These are my go-to boots: the "Danner Tachyon 8-inch Black Hot" [https://www.danner.com/tachyon-8-black.html](https://www.danner.com/tachyon-8-black.html)  
  
I first bought them because I needed a wide boot. That was the non-negotiable requirement. They also had to be lightweight, comfortable, and usable in hot weather, but “comes in wide” was the first filter. Once you need wide boots, shopping gets less like browsing and more like checking whether any company remembers that feet can be different shapes.  
  
The Tachyons fit the job well. They are light, comfortable, breathable, and good in heat. They are also tactical boots, which means they look ready to rappel off a municipal building while mostly being used to go to the store, walk around town, and occasionally make poor footwear decisions outdoors.  
  
They are not true hiking boots. The tread is fine on normal ground, but slick rocks, wet roots, mud, and mossy nonsense are not where they shine. They are more of an urban tactical boot that can tolerate a trail than a hiking boot that wants to spend its life in the woods.  
  
I learned this during a hike that was less “wet trail” and more “walking directly up a stream with occasional archaeological evidence that a trail had once existed.”  
  
Early into the hike, I realized I had made a tactical error of my own. I was about 200 miles from home, had no other footwear with me, and had a Wesleyan University campus tour with my son a few hours later.  
  
My first thought was that I was basically fucked for the rest of the trip.  
  
At first, I tried to avoid the water. This was foolish. The trail was water. There was no elegant route around it. Every attempt to hop from rock to rock just added the possibility of slipping, soaking the boots anyway, and arriving at Wesleyan with a campus-tour story that began, “So I fell into a stream while trying to save my tactical shoes.”  
  
Eventually I committed.  
  
The Tachyons got fully soaked. Not damp. Not “a little water got in.” Fully soaked. Portable-aquarium soaked. Every step made that disturbing wet-boot sound, like two watermelons in tactical nylon bags being carried through a drainage ditch.  
  
They are not waterproof. To their credit, they do not pretend to be waterproof. Water entered immediately, efficiently, and without requiring a warranty claim or a press conference.  
  
After the hike, I changed into dry socks, put the same soaked boots back on, and went to the Wesleyan tour because there was no other option. I was prepared to spend the afternoon squishing around campus, trying to look interested in academic buildings while quietly resenting my own footwear.  
  
But during the tour, I noticed something strange.  
  
The boots were not bothering me.  
  
My feet were comfortable. Nothing felt cold. Nothing was squishing. I was not distracted by damp socks or mentally calculating the distance to the nearest shoe store. At some point, I had simply forgotten that I had hiked through a stream in them.  
  
After the tour, I remembered.  
  
I checked the boots.  
  
They were dry.  
  
Completely dry.  
  
That was the impressive part. No boot dryer. No newspaper stuffing. No heater. No hair dryer held at an unsafe angle in a hotel room. No emergency tourist sneakers. I changed socks, kept wearing the boots, and within a few hours they had dried while still on my feet.  
  
That is where lightweight, breathable footwear can beat waterproof boots. Waterproof boots are great right up until water gets inside. Then you are walking around in two leather-lined bathtubs. The Tachyons take the opposite approach. They get wet fast, but they also dry fast enough that the whole problem can disappear before you have time to become truly miserable.  
  
The only thing missing was a watermelon. Had I been carrying one, it would probably have been the driest object in the entire watershed, sitting on a rock judging my footwork.  
  
I used to buy them for around $90. The last pair I bought cost $180, which is kind of absurd. Even at $90, I thought that was a little high for what is basically lightweight synthetic tactical-running-shoe material with an ankle collar. At $180, I am paying a premium price for boots that could probably be described as “aggressively ventilated sneakers for people who own flashlights.”  
  
Still, I keep buying them. They come in wide, they are light, comfortable, and good in hot weather. They are not my first choice for slick hiking conditions, but they passed a very specific real-world test: surviving an accidental stream hike, then quietly drying themselves in time for a campus tour 200 miles from home.  
  
The watermelon remains untested in this footwear system, but I have confidence it would have been comfortable.

3 bumps

hyokkim · 7/2/2026, 3:22:46 PM · permalink

''I first bought them because I needed a wide boot. That was the non-negotiable requirement. They also had to be lightweight, comfortable, and usable in hot weather, but “comes in wide” was the first filter. Once you need wide boots, shopping gets less like browsing and more like checking whether any company remembers that feet can be different shapes.

The Tachyons fit the job well. They are light, comfortable, breathable, and good in heat. They are also tactical boots, which means they look ready to rappel off a municipal building while mostly being used to go to the store, walk around town, and occasionally make poor footwear decisions outdoors.

They are not true hiking boots. The tread is fine on normal ground, but slick rocks, wet roots, mud, and mossy nonsense are not where they shine. They are more of an urban tactical boot that can tolerate a trail than a hiking boot that wants to spend its life in the woods.''  
  
I totally agree; my daily choice today is Hoka.  
  
https://www.hoka.com/en/us/mens-recovery-comfort-shoes/bondi-sr/1110520.html?dwvar_1110520_color=BBLC  
  
When I need ankle support, I just use puttee, ideally ankle length puttee, gives better ankle support than any combat boots.  It also makes it lighter weight as well.  
  
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puttee  
  
Compared to boots, they are far more compact, and lighter weight, so one can easily carry a spare; one can be issued two pairs so that when one gets into situation like this, one can simply wear the dry socks, and dry shoes, dry puttee, after getting out of the situation while hooking the wet shoes/socks/puttee on the outside of the backpack to dry.   Heck, one could easily carry even 3 pairs, in case, when there is no Sun out to dry them.  
  
Ideally, one could wear 'waterproof' boots when raining or light lighter/mud situation, especially when it gets cold.   Under hot weather in the similar situation, one could simply go 'Texas', and wear non water permeable sandal.  
  
Btw. that's what IJA did during campaign in SE Asia when crossing a river; they took off all their uniform/boots/gears, and put them in waterproof bag.     
  
In Winter/snow situation, I find jackboots to be really handy, no lacings, easy to put on and take off, also handy during Spring/Fall mud season as well, very easy to take care of due to no lacing.    Why the importance of a gun being mud reliable, such as AR15, or Luger.  
  
One could carry snow shoe or ski during Winter as well.

1 bump

Signature