Comment on Paul VS. Mohammed: DO YOU REALISE THEY ARE THE SAME ARCHETYPE? by q2025

Parent Post: Paul VS. Mohammed: DO YOU REALISE THEY ARE THE SAME ARCHETYPE?

q2025 · 11/11/2025, 7:08:15 PM · permalink

15 bumps

lucky_skyblzr · 11/11/2025, 7:21:52 PM · permalink

11 bumps

q2025 · 11/11/2025, 7:46:39 PM · permalink

8 bumps

lucky_skyblzr · 11/11/2025, 10:33:10 PM · permalink

7 bumps

q2025 · 11/12/2025, 5:02:45 AM · permalink

Peace upon you bro.  
  
First, thank you for your honesty about your opinions about Paul being your own thoughts, rather an researched analysis. Appreciated.   
  
Second, I can tell from your statements that either you're getting your information from thrid party sources and those are sometimes biased or uninformed.  
  
For example, yes, you're right, many muslims consider Muhammad to be infallible. But that's a mistaken cultural phenomenon, and not the truth of Islam. So within the Quran there are at least 3 instances where God reprimands or corrects Muhammad (examples below). And there are quotes of Muhammad that reinforce that he is a man who makes mistakes, and shouldn't be considered infallible (examples below also).  
  
Do some people still consider Muhammad infallible? Yes, but thats because of their own ignorance,  and the trachings of ignorant preachers, not because its what Islam teaches in the Quran.  
  
If you want to arrive at the truth, you'll need to distinguish between the teachings of the Quran and the teachings \[and actions\] of muslims. For example, you'll find many muslims saying the punishment for blasphemy is death... but if you read the Quran you find out that's totally not true. Similarly, you'll find many muslims saying it's their duty to convert people, but when you read Quran you discover thats not exactly true either.  
  
Peace Upon You Bro. May we all find guidance and mercy.  
  
&lt;=====&gt;  
  
Qur'anic Ayat  
[80:1-2](https://quran.com/abasa): "He frowned and turned away because the blind man came to him \[interrupting\]..."

Context: Muhammad was speaking to political leaders of Mecca, when a blind man interrupted,  seeking advice on some matter. Muhammad frowned at the interruptions, which God did not like, and pointed out. The passage goes on to explain that perhaps the blind man was righteous or might have benefited from Muhammad's advice, whereas the political leaders were arrogant and Godless.

[9:43](https://quran.com/at-tawbah/43) "May Allah pardon you \[O Muhammad\]. \[But\] Why did you give them permission \[to not battle\]? \[You should not have\] until it was evident to you who were truthful and you knew the liars."

Context: Allah reproves Muhammad for excusing hypocrites from the battle to defend Medina, without first verifying their claims.

[66:1](https://quran.com/at-tahrim): "O Prophet, why do you prohibit \[yourself from\] what Allah has made lawful for you, seeking to please your wives? And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful."

Context: Allah admonishes Muhammad for forbidding himself honey to appease a wife.

4 bumps

q2025 · 11/12/2025, 5:05:15 AM · permalink

2 bumps

Signature